Managing the climate rent : How can regulators implement intertemporally efficient mitigation policies ? ∗
نویسندگان
چکیده
This paper provides a formal framework to analyse informational and commitment requirements of several intertemporal price and quantity instruments for mitigating global warming. We ask under what conditions and to what extend the regulator can shift the complex and daunting intertemporal optimization of fossil resource use to markets. Mitigation always generates an intertemporal climate rent which reflects the stock-dependent damages and emerging scarcities of the atmospheric carbon deposit. In order to calculate and to manage this climate rent appropriately, common policy instruments like Pigouvian taxes or emissions trading presume perfect information about resource demand, extraction costs, reserve sizes and damages for the entire planning horizon. To reduce these informational requirements we develop an alternative policy approach – a state dependent tax rule – that relies only on current observations of cumulative extraction (or atmospheric carbon concentration). Within a cost-benefit analysis, this instrument is capable to shift the complex intertemporal optimization problem completely to the resource sector when resource owners are homogeneous. Under a cost-effective carbon budget approach, emissions trading with banking and borrowing can also unburden the regulator from solving the intertemporal social planner optimization problem. Additionally, we discuss which instruments can obtain an optimal allocation even if resource owners employ discount rate mark-ups (i.e. due to imperfect commitment or insecure property rights). While an emissions trading scheme without banking and borrowing is robust against discount rate mark-ups, resource taxes have to be modified in order to achieve an optimal allocation. Abbreviations: BAU – business-as-usual; CBA – cost-benefit analysis; ETS – emissions trading scheme; ITR – intertemporal trading rate
منابع مشابه
Correction to: household preferences for reducing greenhouse gas emissions in four European high-income countries: does health information matter? A mixed-methods study protocol
BACKGROUND It is now universally acknowledged that climate change constitutes a major threat to human health. At the same time, some of the measures to reduce greenhouse gas emissions, so-called climate change mitigation measures, have significant health co-benefits (e.g., walking or cycling more; eating less meat). The goal of limiting global warming to 1,5° Celsius set by the Conference of th...
متن کاملEfficiency and Acceptability of Climate Policies: Race Against the Lock-ins
Policymakers have good reasons to favor capital-based policies – such as CAFE standards or feebates programs – over a carbon price. A carbon price minimizes the discounted cost of a climate policy, but may result in existing capital being under-utilized or scrapped before its scheduled lifetime, hurt the workers that depend on it, and inflict an immediate income drop. Capital-based policies avo...
متن کاملManaging Risk in a Derivative IaaS Cloud
Infrastructure-as-a-Service (IaaS) cloud platforms rent computing resources with different cost and availability tradeoffs. For example, users may acquire virtual machines (VMs) in the spot market that are cheap, but can be unilaterally terminated by the cloud operator. Because of this revocation risk, spot servers have been conventionally used for delay and risk tolerant batch jobs. In this pa...
متن کاملHousehold preferences for reducing greenhouse gas emissions in four European high-income countries: Does health information matter? A mixed-methods study protocol
Background: It is now universally acknowledged that climate change constitutes a major threat to human health. At the same time, some of the measures to reduce greenhouse gas emissions, so-called climate change mitigation measures, have significant health co-benefits (e.g., walking or cycling more; eating less meat). The goal of limiting global warming to 1,5° Celsius set by the Conference of t...
متن کاملAn Analysis with ReMIND
The present study analyzes the deployment of technologies to reduce CO2 emission in the global energy sector and the implied costs using the energy-economy-climate model ReMIND. The results depend on the policy chosen for inducing changes of investments. Climate policies price emissions and therefore induce changes of investments. The mitigation costs of less than 1% of GDP are relatively small...
متن کامل